Verdict at a glance
Pick Plum if
Pick Plum if you want saving to happen automatically without thinking about it.
How we compared: published fees, account types and review scores for each, verified against the provider’s own price pages.
The short version
Moneybox is stronger on ISAs, Lifetime ISAs and pensions; Plum is stronger on automated saving rules and everyday money. Both charge a monthly fee on top of fund costs, and neither shows you how the pot maps to your actual retirement.
Why people compare them
The two headline UK automatic-saving apps, both of which push you into a Stocks and Shares ISA.
Price and fit, side by side
| Feature | Plum | Moneybox |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest paid plan | PlumFree tier, then £3.99 per month | Moneybox£1 per month |
| Free tier | PlumYes | MoneyboxNo |
| Billed in pounds | PlumYes | MoneyboxYes |
| Best for | PlumPeople who want saving to happen automatically without thinking about it | MoneyboxPeople starting to invest who want the round-up habit and a Lifetime ISA in the same app |
Where Plum wins
- A genuinely free Basic tier that includes automations, a Cash ISA and a Lifetime ISA
- Automated saving rules work well for people who never get round to transferring money manually
- Investment management fees fall as you move up the tiers, from 0.60% on Basic to 0.15% on Max
Where Moneybox wins
- Properly UK: Cash ISA, Stocks and Shares ISA, Lifetime ISA, GIA and pension all in one place
- Round-ups genuinely get people saving who otherwise would not
- Pension accounts carry no monthly subscription fee, and the platform fee tapers above £100,000
Where both fall short
- Neither projects far enough forward to answer a long-term question.
If neither is quite right
If what you actually want is the retirement answer rather than a better dashboard, that is the gap Delphina was built for: UK pensions, ISAs and tax, projected to the age you want to stop. It does not do the job Plum does for people who want saving to happen automatically without thinking about it, so if that is the real problem, Plum is still the better buy. Free plan is £0, no card.
Plum vs Moneybox Lifetime ISA
Moneybox offers both a Cash Lifetime ISA and a Stocks and Shares Lifetime ISA. Plum's Lifetime ISA is a cash account, available on every plan, including the free Basic plan. Whichever you hold, the government adds 25% to what you pay in, on up to £4,000 a tax year, so up to £1,000. On Moneybox's Cash LISA there is no service fee: Moneybox keeps any difference between the interest it receives from its partner banks and the rate it pays you. Its Stocks and Shares LISA carries the standard investing fees of 0.15% or 0.45% plus the £1 monthly subscription unless waived. Plum lists no fee for its Lifetime ISA.
- Moneybox Stocks and Shares Lifetime ISA: the same 0.15% or 0.45% service fee as its other investing accounts, plus the £1 monthly subscription unless it is waived. Uninvested cash carries no service fee.
- Plum Lifetime ISA: a cash Lifetime ISA, included on every plan, including the free Basic plan. Plum lists no fee for it.
- Government bonus on both: 25% on contributions up to £4,000 per tax year (so up to £1,000 a year).
- Withdrawal penalty on both: 25% government charge on any amount withdrawn before age 60 unless you are buying your first home (up to £4,000 of the withdrawal can be penalty-free under the first-home rule).
- Cash or invested: Moneybox lets you choose a cash or a stocks and shares Lifetime ISA. Plum's Lifetime ISA holds cash, so it earns interest rather than investment returns.
Plum vs Moneybox fees
The two apps charge very differently. Moneybox charges a £1 monthly subscription on its investing accounts, waived at £5,000 or more, plus a 0.15% or 0.45% service fee depending on the funds you hold. Plum's Basic plan is free, its paid plans cost £3.99 to £14.99 a month, and its Stocks and Shares ISA fee falls from 0.60% to 0.15% as the plan goes up.
- Plum fees: Basic is free, Plus is £3.99 a month, Boost £7.99 and Max £14.99, and paid plans are free for the first month. The Stocks and Shares ISA carries a 0.60% service fee, with rebates that bring the net fee to 0.45% on Plus, 0.30% on Boost and 0.15% on Max.
- Moneybox fees: 0.15% a year on Moneybox funds or 0.45% on other funds, plus £1 a month, free for the first three months and waived once you hold £5,000 or more with Moneybox. Uninvested cash in investment accounts carries no service fee.
- On a £5,000 Stocks and Shares ISA, Moneybox costs £22.50 a year in non-Moneybox funds or £7.50 in its own funds, with the subscription waived. Plum costs £30 a year on Basic, about £70 on Plus (£47.88 subscription plus £22.50) and about £111 on Boost. Plum's subscription also pays for features beyond investing. Fund charges are extra on both.
See where you actually stand, free
Track your net worth, assets and a five-year forecast built on your real position, not a guess. Free plan, no card.
See where I standDecided? Here’s the next question.
The verdict on the platform is one question. Whether you’re actually saving enough is another, and Delphina answers it from what you already hold and what you pay in each month.
Free. No card required. About two minutes.
Plum vs Moneybox: common questions
Plum is £3.99 per month and Moneybox is £1 per month. Compare the billing period before the number: an annual price and a monthly price are not the same thing.
You can, and some people do, because they solve different halves of the problem. It does mean paying for both, so add the two annual figures together before deciding.
Judge it on billing currency, Open Banking coverage and whether ISAs and pensions are handled. Check each one against those three points, because a tool that scores well elsewhere can still be a poor fit in the UK.
Plum suits people who want saving to happen automatically without thinking about it. Moneybox suits people starting to invest who want the round-up habit and a lifetime isa in the same app. The one that matches how you already think about money will take less setting up.
Plum scores 4.7/5 on Apple App Store (GB) from 70,838 ratings. Moneybox scores 4.8/5 on Apple App Store (GB) from 77,185 ratings. Weigh the volume as well as the score.
Delphina covers the gap both leave, which is UK pensions, ISAs and tax projected forward to retirement. The trade-off is that it does not do the job Plum does for people who want saving to happen automatically without thinking about it, so if that is the real need, pick one of these two.