Educational use only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

A Few Quid vs A custom Excel spreadsheet: which to pick

A Few Quid is sold explicitly as the thing that replaces your retirement spreadsheet, so anyone considering it is usually deciding whether to stop maintaining their own model.

Information, not financial advice. Prices and terms change; check each provider before you buy.

Verdict at a glance

Pick A Few Quid if

Pick A Few Quid if you're happy to type your own numbers in and want a cheap, UK-tax-aware projection engine, not a connected picture of every account.

Pick A custom Excel spreadsheet if

Pick A custom Excel spreadsheet if you want total control over every assumption and genuinely enjoy building the model yourself.

How we compared: published fees, account types and review scores for each, verified against the provider’s own price pages.

The short version

A spreadsheet is free and does exactly what you tell it, including the mistakes; A Few Quid gives you UK tax bands, allowances and pension rules already wired in for £36.99 a year. Both still depend on you remembering to update the numbers, which is the failure mode that eventually gets either one.

Why people compare them

A Few Quid is sold explicitly as the thing that replaces your retirement spreadsheet, so anyone considering it is usually deciding whether to stop maintaining their own model.

Price and fit, side by side

A Few Quid and A custom Excel spreadsheet compared feature by feature.
Cheapest paid planA Few Quid£36.99 per yearA custom Excel spreadsheetFree tier, then £84.99 per year
Free tierA Few QuidNoA custom Excel spreadsheetYes
Billed in poundsA Few QuidYesA custom Excel spreadsheetYes
Best forA Few QuidUK savers who are happy to type their own numbers in and want a cheap, UK-tax-aware projection engine rather than a connected picture of their moneyA custom Excel spreadsheetPeople who want total control over every assumption and genuinely enjoy building the model

Where A Few Quid wins

  • Built for UK rules from the ground up: income tax bands, NI, CGT, dividend allowance, ISA and SIPP wrappers and the state pension
  • Natural-language scenario setup, so "what if I retire at 55?" builds the projection rather than asking you to fill in a form
  • Unusually good property modelling for the price, including stamp duty, overpayments, rent-vs-buy and buy-to-let under Section 24 versus a limited company

Where A custom Excel spreadsheet wins

  • Complete flexibility: if you can define the rule, you can model it, with no vendor deciding what is supported
  • No subscription lock-in to a planning vendor, and your file keeps working whatever happens to any company
  • Your data never leaves your machine unless you choose to sync it, so nothing is shared with a third party

Decided? Here’s the next question.

The verdict on the platform is one question. Whether you’re actually saving enough is another, and Delphina answers it from what you already hold and what you pay in each month.

Free. No card required. About two minutes.

A Few Quid vs A custom Excel spreadsheet: common questions

A Few Quid is £36.99 per year and A custom Excel spreadsheet is £84.99 per year. Compare the billing period before the number: an annual price and a monthly price are not the same thing.

You can, and some people do, because they solve different halves of the problem. It does mean paying for both, so add the two annual figures together before deciding.

Judge it on billing currency, Open Banking coverage and whether ISAs and pensions are handled. Check each one against those three points, because a tool that scores well elsewhere can still be a poor fit in the UK.

A Few Quid suits uk savers who are happy to type their own numbers in and want a cheap, uk-tax-aware projection engine rather than a connected picture of their money. A custom Excel spreadsheet suits people who want total control over every assumption and genuinely enjoy building the model. The one that matches how you already think about money will take less setting up.

Compare these individually

Other comparisons