Both are FCA-regulated and FSCS-protected. The real difference is fees, account types and how each platform feels to use. Verified against each provider’s published charges.
Fees verified October 2026. Capital at risk. Information, not financial advice.
Beginners building a habit, and first-time buyers using the Lifetime ISA.
Self-directed investors who want low-cost, no-platform-fee share dealing from a major UK bank.
Tick what you need. No account, no email. The answer is on this page.
Tick what you need above and we'll tell you which of the two covers it.
Account availability verified October 2026. Capital at risk. Information, not financial advice.
Users love the round-ups, the goal-based design and how painless it makes starting. 93% of customers surveyed in 2026 would recommend it.
The £1 monthly subscription on top of the platform fee is often flagged as expensive for balances under £5,000.
Read Moneybox reviews on TrustpilotLong-standing customers value the low flat-fee share dealing and the Lloyds Banking Group backing; recent reviews praise the move into the Scottish Widows app.
Common gripes are the 1.5% FX fee on US shares and the dated feel of parts of the web platform.
Read Scottish Widows reviews on Trustpilot| Fee | Moneybox | Scottish Widows |
|---|---|---|
| Platform fee | £1/month subscription (waived at £5,000+) plus 0.15% to 0.45% platform fee | £0 on ISA and Share Dealing Account; SIPP 0.25% capped at £16.50/month |
| Share dealing | US stocks available, 0.45% FX fee | £5.00 per UK trade (£0 commission on international, 1.5% FX applies) |
| Fund dealing | Free (fund fees apply) | £5.00 per trade |
| FX fee | 0.45% on US stocks | 1.5% |
| Stocks & Shares ISA | Subscription plus 0.15% on Moneybox funds or 0.45% on other funds | No annual charge |
| SIPP | 0.45% on the first £100k then 0.15% (other funds); 0.15% capped at £150 a year (Moneybox funds); no subscription | 0.25% per year, capped at £198 |
| Withdrawals | Free | Free (CHAPS same-day payment £25) |
| Minimum to start | £1 | £50 |
Put in your own numbers. Nothing is saved and there is no sign-up.
Over 20 years, paying 0.25% a year more in charges on £50,000 leaves you about £5,903 worse off.
That is one account. Add your ISAs and pensions to a free Delphina account and it works this out for all of them, and whether you are on track for the retirement you want.
Create a free accountFree plan, no card. About two minutes.
Illustrative: a lump sum growing at 5% a year before charges (0.25% vs 0.5% a year), no further contributions, no tax. Not a recommendation of Moneybox or Scottish Widows. Delphina is guidance, not financial advice.
Moneybox is designed for getting started. Round-ups, weekly deposits and simple starter portfolios remove the friction that stops most people investing, and its Lifetime ISA is one of the most popular routes to a first home deposit.
The convenience has a cost on small balances: £1 a month plus up to 0.45% is one of the higher fee stacks here below £5,000 in non-Moneybox funds. The subscription drops away at £5,000, and Moneybox's own funds carry 0.15% rather than 0.45%, so the total depends on your pot size and fund choice.
Scottish Widows Share Dealing is the rebranded IWeb platform, now run by Halifax Share Dealing Limited inside Lloyds Banking Group. It charges no annual fee on the ISA or General Investment Account, £5 per UK trade and free regular investing through a Regular Investment Plan. For a buy-and-hold investor making occasional trades, the all-in cost can be very low.
The trade-off is the 1.5% FX charge on US and other non-GBP trades, which adds up quickly for global investors, and no Junior ISA. The SIPP is competitively priced at 0.25% capped at £16.50 a month. Compare it against Trading 212 or Freetrade if FX cost matters, and against AJ Bell or Hargreaves Lansdown if you want funds and full-service support.
It depends on what you hold and how often you trade. Moneybox's platform fee is £1/month subscription (waived at £5,000+) plus 0.15% to 0.45% platform fee, against £0 on ISA and Share Dealing Account; SIPP 0.25% capped at £16.50/month at Scottish Widows. On dealing, Moneybox charges US stocks available, 0.45% FX fee for shares and free (fund fees apply) for funds, while Scottish Widows charges £5.00 per UK trade (£0 commission on international, 1.5% FX applies) for shares and £5.00 per trade for funds. Fees verified October 2026.
Moneybox is best for beginners building a habit, and first-time buyers using the Lifetime ISA. Scottish Widows is best for self-directed investors who want low-cost, no-platform-fee share dealing from a major UK bank. Both are FCA regulated and covered by the FSCS.
On Moneybox's ISA: Subscription plus 0.15% on Moneybox funds or 0.45% on other funds. On Scottish Widows's ISA: No annual charge. Scottish Widows offers a flexible ISA and Moneybox does not. Minimums are £1 at Moneybox and £50 at Scottish Widows.
Moneybox does not offer a SIPP. Scottish Widows offers a SIPP (0.25% per year, capped at £198).
Moneybox scores 4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot (Excellent) from around 4,800 reviews. Scottish Widows scores 4.6 out of 5 (Excellent) from over 13,000 reviews. The £1 monthly subscription on top of the platform fee is often flagged as expensive for balances under £5,000. Common gripes are the 1.5% FX fee on US shares and the dated feel of parts of the web platform.
Yes. UK platforms accept ISA and SIPP transfers in, and you start the transfer with the receiving provider rather than the one you are leaving. Moneybox charges free on withdrawals and Scottish Widows charges free (CHAPS same-day payment £25). Transfer as cash and you are out of the market while it settles; transfer in specie and you keep your holdings but it takes longer.
Moneybox or Scottish Widows, the account is the easy part. What decides when you can retire is how much goes in and for how long. Delphina works that out from what you already hold and what you pay in each month.
Free plan. No card required. Takes about two minutes.